A Comparison between Coil Framing Nailers and Stick Nailers
Which is better between a coil framing nailer and a stick nailer? This has always been a question for the ages. Big carpentry work usually require a very heavy usage of nails. Using hundreds to even thousands of nails is fairly common depending on the scale of the project. Hammering these nails manually is always an option but not an efficient one. In this case, either a coil framing nailer or stick nailer would be ideal. So here it comes: which one is better? Let’s find out.
Coil Framing Nailer vs Stick Nailer
Both types of nailers are frequently seen at job sites and are used for framing. Even though coil nailers are not used as often as stick nailers when it comes to framing, they are still a very versatile tool nonetheless. See EVERWIN’s range of framing nailers here.
What is a Coil Nailer?
Coil nailers generally hold 200~300 nails in their canister, depending on the type and size of the nails. The two most common types of nails used are:
- Framing nails
- Sheathing nails
Since the loading capacity is high, users don’t have to reload that often, which in turn saves a lot of time.
Coil nailers are oftentimes fairly compact, meaning using them in tight spaces isn’t a problem. However, with their amazing maneuverability comes a downside: weight.
A fully loaded canister can increase the weight of the tool by a large margin and create fatigue for the users quite easily. As a result, a stick nailer is recommended for overhead work due to its lower weight.
What is a Stick Nailer?
A stick nailer has a high compatibility when it comes to nails. However, with this comes a downside: Users will have to make sure that the nail has the right angle and collation style to fit the nailer.
A stick nailer consists of two magazines that hold 25~40 nails each, so there is a lot more reloading to do. However, in exchange, it also brings less fatigue due to its lower weight. The average stick nailer will be able to hold the following nail types:
- Plastic collated round head nails between 17 degrees ~ 18 degrees
- Plastic collated round head nails between 20 degrees ~ 22 degrees
- Wire collated D-head nails between 27 degrees ~ 28 degrees
- Paper collated D-head or offset head nails between 30 degrees ~ 34 degrees
That being said, users will need to follow local rules and codes which may potentially rule out the usage of certain nail types. As a result, it is absolutely important to pay attention to the acceptable nail types when you’re making your purchase.
While the function of these two tools is essentially the same, their designs and features are quite different. Some of the key comparisons are shown below.
- Weight- A fully loaded coil nailer can easily weigh 10 pounds and even more depending on the model. As a result, having to hold one of these overhead for a long time can easily bring fatigue. That being said, Stick nailers weigh much less due to their smaller magazine capacity and in turn also creates less fatigue when operated over a long period of time.
- Capacity- If you’re working on something that requires a lot of nails, you probably wouldn’t want to have to reload every 50 nails. In this case, a coil nailer would fit better for your job due to its large loading capacity.
- Loading- Coil nailers use round canisters with a loop design that allows for rapid firing and minimizes jams. Stick nailers on the other hand use magazines with nail strips that increases the overall length of the tool.
- Nail pricing- In terms of prices, the nails for stick nailers are oftentimes far more expensive than that of coil nailers coil nailers aren’t that dependent on certain angle nails and hence they’re easier to fill.
- Jamming- Stick nailers are more prone to jamming compared to coil nailers due to its magazine design.
Choosing the right model is as subjective as it gets; there is certainly no right or wrong answer. Nonetheless, we recommend a coil nailer if the working area is small and there is less space to operate due to the tool’s compactness and maneuverability.
However, if you have a pouch with you, stick nailers would be the better option since they’re easier to reload. Make sure you bring enough nails with you for reloading and you’ll be able to save a lot of time on the process itself too. Nevertheless, coil nailers would still be able to save you more time since they’re generally less jam-prone.
We hope with the better understanding on the differences between coil nailers and sticker nailers you’ve gained after reading this article, you’ll be more prepared for your future work and projects.